Internet Horology Club 185
Floor versus Wall Clock Debate, 1870s Style

This topic can be found at:
https://ihc185.infopop.cc/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/9886029761/m/1283904487

January 19, 2015, 22:24
Michael P. McNamee
Floor versus Wall Clock Debate, 1870s Style
For two years I've been debating whether to get a grandfather clock as opposed to a large wall clock for my family room. I finally decided on a 42-inch Waterbury "Regulator 82" wall clock. Although the room is easily large enough to accommodate a wall clock of that size, I finally had to admit that a 9-10 foot floor clock would be too much, even for a room with a 12-foot ceiling.

While agonizing over the decision, a pair of wonderful 1870's songs came to mind. The first requires no introduction, as it is one of the best-loved American folk tunes ever written (although I'm guessing that a lot of folks aren't familiar with the third and fourth verses). It was composed by Henry C. Work in 1876. There's a wonderful rendition of all four verses, performed by a terrific vocalist named Tom Roush, at:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eWwTNQBRLxw

What many may not be familiar with is the equally poignant sequel, written two years later, in which Mr. Work deplores the ugly fate of his grandfather's clock and castigates "that vain, stuck-up thing on the wall." You can hear Mr. Roush's rendition at:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FQA6SwM8g0M

Both of these videos feature period sheet music and period advertising. Very cool, if you're moved by this sort of thing. Smile

Mike
January 20, 2015, 10:12
Tim Poovey
Enjoyed the videos Mike, brought a smile to my day.

Thanks for posting!

Tim
January 20, 2015, 12:10
Buster Beck
I think it would depend on one's taste as to a large wall clock or Grandfather clock. Both are fairly loud tickers in a quiet room but I give the edge to my Grandfather clock with it's Westminster Chimes.

A word of caution though, overnight guests always complain next morning about the ticking in the middle of the night and the chimes, but I rarely hear either !! Maybe I need to "buy" some new guests !!

regards,
bb
January 20, 2015, 13:25
Lorne Wasylishen
Cool, thank you Michael, I knew I had heard that music before. This is a pleasing female rendition sprinkled throughout a CBC documentary called "Too Tall For the Shelf, The Grandfather Clock".

The first part is about the only watchmakers school left in Canada, then a piece about a train ride, then is the story of The Grandfather Clock.

Just drag the slider to the 24 minute mark for The Grandfather Clock but the whole thing is time well spent. It will play while you open another window and search the internet for pocket watches. Smile

It's About Time
January 21, 2015, 22:18
Michael P. McNamee
Glad you guys enjoyed the videos!

Lorne, I clicked on the link, but the video would not expand. Great music, though!
February 06, 2015, 00:35
Donald Hawes
I know what Buster means about guests complaining. I have to stop all six of my wind & chime clocks every time my daughter comes with her family for a visit. It's a pain getting them all restarted with the correct time. Also like Buster, I never really notice the ticking & chiming much except when I'm having a long night.
February 06, 2015, 08:43
Dave Turner
Michael, How about putting up a picture of you Waterbury?


Dave Turner
February 15, 2015, 20:59
Michael P. McNamee
Absolutely, Dave. Sorry for the delayed response. Here it is: