I would go with "B" one reason being, sometimes I think I might have spotted a missing watch but then I have trouble finding where it was originally posted & trying a search by serial number does not always return with any results.

Tom

POCKET WATCH DISCUSSIONS is such a generic title that anytime a logical grouping can be cut out and given its own 'domain' makes sense to me. Such action would bring more attention to the subject. I believe this domain should be open to any person (member of IHC, or not) who has had a theft of horological items as we all can be victims of a thief. A cross listing of stolen items with other forums would be nice. I am horrified by stories of ebay watch sellers who have had valuable watches/clocks returned after buyers have stolen valuable parts - returning them with cheaper substitutes. I understand ebay sellers can no longer diss buyers.
Finally, a recent item here where IHC members made up a loss of watch hands that were stolen really showed me what our members are like... and I LIKE it! When a story of woe is told, IHC steps up to the plate when ever possible.
M.

I like the B choice. Putting lost or stolen items with the general discussions get lost in the discussions. Giving them their own section makes sense to me.

I also believe the "B" choice is the way to go,always there easy to find, etc, and if we stay on topic with it, very useful.
Bill

It's "B" for me as well. It would be helpful for each thread to be titled by discription and serial number.

"B" for me! Also, if the items are NOT stolen from the mail, and you've made a report to the appropriate law enforcement, make sure they have serial numbers and case (watch) numbers to enter into the computer system. Follow up through a Postal Inspector if the theft was from the mail, as your local postmaster may just figure insurance as the cost of doing businesss. Make sure the numbers get into the national system(NCIC). Remember the case numbers must be entered as well, because those folks who aren't watch people may take the case number for the serial of the watch.

Bob

I am for the "B" option, too many topics get buried in the regular Pocket Watch Discussions.

Larry

Agreed - the B option would allow for a Lost and Perhaps Someday Found reference section.

I am no different than all the others that have replied....
I agree with Mitch in that each watch should have it's personal thread with description and serial number....
Also, I agree with Bob, that each case number should be listed....
In addition, if photos of the watch / clock are available they should be posted as well....

The main Topic "LOST OR STOLEN WATCHES/CLOCKS" should be on the front page and open to everyone, member or not....

That's my take, there will be others....we need as much participation as possible....

Regards,

Jerry

Thanks, Jerry.

The reason I suggested the individual threads begin with discription and serial number is that the finding of each thread would be easier, at least for me. If each thread began,"My Great Watch was Stolen!" you'd have a lengthy search ahead of you.

I also vote for "B', for all the reasons already stated.

I will go with option "B", as a specific forum would be easier to navigate. I also agree with a separate topic for each item with as much information as possible for that item.

Thank you, Lindell, for offering a part of IHC185 for this subject. The more eyes there are looking for stolen watches and clocks, the greater the chance for recovery.

I also will vote for option B

Option B is the way to go. It's just sad that we need to have a topic dedicated to stolen watches.

Ray

I vote for "B" also. It would be nice to maintain a link to a list of stolen stuff grouped by clocks and watches and listed by serial numbers (single sequential list) and also alpha listing by manufacturer. I would be glad to help arrange the watch listing and maintain it if another IHC185'er could help with the clocks, and co-editing.(I make mistakes).

B

B, please!

Wayne

B as well.

Regards! Mark