Internet Horology Club 185
My $1.66 BW Raymond Odd Fellows
July 28, 2008, 23:06
Tom BrownMy $1.66 BW Raymond Odd Fellows
Last week on Ebay I ran across a buy it now of this pocket watch & two wrist watches for $5.00 plus $4.80 shipping.
I thought I would post photos of this pocket watch & dial. The watch is an 18s BWR, the photos of the movement are as I received it, I have not cleaned it yet, the balance appears OK so far.
July 28, 2008, 23:07
Tom BrownBack of case
July 28, 2008, 23:07
Tom BrownMovement
July 28, 2008, 23:09
Tom BrownThis is the dial after I cleaned it a little, it has one hairline I can see near the 7 minute mark. The dial has gold highlights around some of the symbols but they are hard to show.
July 28, 2008, 23:11
Tom BrownI tried to show some of the gold in this photo.
Who made this type of dial back then, since it is marked Elgin did the factory do these?
I welcome any comments.
Tom
July 28, 2008, 23:24
Sheila GilbertTom,
Now, where was it, that I can punch you over this?

I can't believe I missed this one!
Congratulations on a Great Buy!!!!!!
(Green with Envy)
Sheila
July 28, 2008, 23:28
Darren SandersWow, being an elgin collector, i'm glad to see you have such a unique find for only $5. On the other hand I cant believe i missed such a great find/buy.
Im not much on the symbols but i love the globe on the seconds dial.
July 29, 2008, 00:17
Ray HallenbeckTom,
Looks like a factory Elgin dial number 1135 on page 73 of Roy Ehrhardt's Elgin ID and price guide (the yellow book).
Great find by the way..
Ray
July 29, 2008, 00:25
Tom BrownRay
Thanks for the info, that is one book I don't have yet.
Thanks Shiela & Darren for the comments, I think some of these buy it now items you just have to be there before someone else sees it. I don't see how it is worth the sellers time & gas to sell so cheap. They said they were cleaning out their grandparents estate, I wish I had something like this from my grandparents.
I also like the earth in the seconds too.
I posted the two wrist watches it came with on the wrist watch page, I don't know anything about wrist watches.
https://ihc185.infopop.cc/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/9886009961/m/9121042713Tom
July 29, 2008, 01:00
David AbbeTHAT IS A GREAT RECOVERY. I APPLAUD YOUR LUCK AND QUICK RESPONSE.
July 29, 2008, 09:05
Tom BrownHere it is after cleaning, oil & new main spring. The crystal came with it, the minute hand was very bent & I straightened it some but it still is a little bent. Seems to be running great at 18002 BPH.
Tom
July 30, 2008, 08:59
Mark CrossWhat a shame.
Ok, I'll help out and send you $20 to take it off your hands. That way you made a little profit.
No?
Oh well. Thought I'd try.

Isn't it neat when you find jems like this under the grim?
GREAT job!
Regards! Mark
July 30, 2008, 20:00
David AbbeI will up that to $25.95. I hope some of your'e good fortune rubs off on the rest of us.
July 30, 2008, 22:24
Tom BrownWell I only report my good buys, unfortuantely I have a good share of bad ones. Just wish I could find the good ones every day. You notice I am not greedy, I only want one a day.
Tom
October 23, 2008, 00:23
Tom BrownWas searching the web & found a on-line business selling an identical watch to this one of mine, there asking price $2500.00
Seems mighty high priced to me.
Tom
October 23, 2008, 12:13
Mark CrossAgreed. My $20 offer still stands, Tom!

Regards! Mark
October 23, 2008, 12:19
Tom BrownMark
I will keep you in mind, I don't think this watch is worth any where close to $2500, I was just amazed to see another one & then to see their asking price.
Tom
October 23, 2008, 17:36
Steve MiddlesworthTom,
Why don't you contact them and see if they will give you $2000.00 for yours.
Steve
October 23, 2008, 17:42
Tom BrownYou know I thought about that Steve but I have a feeling they are like most of these antique store business, they will give you $15.00 for something & then try to resale it for $750.00
Some of the local antique stores I approached in the past about buying some of my watches, but it was strange when I tried to sell them a serviced $200 watch for $100 they would not buy, but they have for sale on their shelves an $80 Elgin for $425. I think the majority of them want to be given the item & then sell it for an outrageous price. I don't mind someone making a profit & even doubling their money I can handle but then greed kicks in on their part.
Tom
October 23, 2008, 17:47
Mark CrossI occasionally run across stores like that, Tom. I even asked one owner why. In HIS case, he KNEW his watches weren't worth what he was asking, but on occasion a picker from 'the big city' (usually New York or Chicago) passes through, and as long as the watches are running, they pay what ever is asked, regardless of what the watch is. So, he marks them up to the outrageous prices we've seen and sometimes actually gets it from these guys!
Regards! Mark
October 23, 2008, 20:36
Tom BrownMark
I know what you mean, last month I spent a week in Milwaukee (my 1st visit), walking the downtown I came to a jeweler that had the most pocket watches on display that I have ever seen in one place (as you can tell I have never been to David Abbe's or Lindell's houses).
Went in the store all excited that I had struck the mother lode. Well after looking at a few & the prices I knew I was in the wrong place. The salesman told me just the day before he had sold a nice 7 jewel 18s Elgin to a gentleman from Florida for $800, I asked was it a sold gold case, nope a gold filled.
Tom
October 24, 2008, 04:28
Sheila GilbertTom,
You can find a few more of these dials at the URL below. They're listed in the Elgin 1896 Materials Catalog too.
Take a look.
http://elginwatches.org/scans/tech_doc/1896_MC/m_pg027_dials.html
Sheila
October 24, 2008, 07:46
Tom BrownSheila
Thanks for the info, I use the Elgin site all the time but it does so many things I do not know how to do but thanks to your posts I have tried a few new things & found info there that I didn't know was there.
I can not learn from any one better than the Elgin Queen.
Tom
ps. I picked up a neat old hard back Elgin Materials book the other day, it was printed in 1904 & is in great shape.