Would an open face dial fom a 23J 16S Vanguard WI fit a 21J open face 16S Crescent Streed WI. The 21 J is a model 1908.

if both are model 1908 I think yes. I have a dial from a vanguard WI on the bench right now and could look at the feet position for comparison if you like.

Jerry it will fit. I had to replace a Crescent St. indicator dial and used one from a 23j Vanguard. I do not know if the dials would have had different details, such as numbers or style but the basic dial is the same.

Jerry,
The dial foot positions on the 16s Waltham models 68, 72, 88, 99 and 08's are all at 18.2 - 38.8 - 57.6.
Hope this helps you out.

Mike

Thanks to all who have replied. Now I need to find one for a 21J Crescent St. that won't break the bank.