Internet Horology Club 185
SOUTH BEND GRADE 294/295 QUESTION

This topic can be found at:
https://ihc185.infopop.cc/eve/forums/a/tpc/f/1086047761/m/54510317

April 21, 2009, 16:33
Andrea Schiavi
SOUTH BEND GRADE 294/295 QUESTION
HELLO,

DOES ANYONE KNOWS IF THE MOVEMENTS SOUTH BEND GRADE 294 OR 295 WERE ALL MARKED?IF NOT, DO THE MARKED ONES COMMAND A PREMIUM PRICE?
ALSO WHICH IS THE FIRST RECORDED SERIAL NUMBER FOR THE GRADE 294 AND THE FIRST ONE FOR THE GRADE 295?

THANK YOU Smile

ANDREA
April 21, 2009, 16:50
Ernie Loga
I don't know if the movements were all marked with 294 or with 295. They made 1000 grade 295 and 1600 grade 294 watches.

The first number recorded for 294 is 445901, the last is 519000.

The first number recorded for 295 469801, the last is 480500.
April 21, 2009, 16:58
Andrea Schiavi
Ernie,
thank you very much!

Andrea
April 21, 2009, 22:16
Andrea Schiavi
I was watching on Ebay this Item number 350190663241

It looks like it is a grade 294. Serial number 445903,only the third ever made! Now according the South Bend database this serial number should be a grade 294.Is it possible that the run of the year 1906,445901-446000,was a mix run of open and hnting case?This watch seems to confirm my guessing.Unfortunately it went to high.. Roll Eyes

Andrea


April 22, 2009, 00:58
Ernie Loga
My guess is the watch sold on Ebay was a doctored watch. If you check out the photos of other 294 and 295 watch movements in the South Bend Research Forum there is some difference. Both have gold lettering. The Ebay example has black lettering. Some paint could change the 294 bridge lettering to black. The 294 has similar damaskeening to other grade South Bends. I believe a train bridge from a worn out 294 was put on watch with similar damaskeening. I would not be surprised to find different serial numbers on other plates.

Also, the wind and ratchet wheels on the Ebay example have some fancy scrolling. the wheels on the 294 and 295 movements in the South Bend Forum have plain wheels.
April 22, 2009, 08:48
Andrea Schiavi
ERNIE,

AT THE BEGINNING I TOUGHT TOO THE TRAIN BRIDGE MIGHT BE OF A GRADE 294.BUT LOOKING AT PAG.381 OF COMPLETE PRICE GUIDE 2008 YOU CAN NOTICE THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE GRADE 295 TRAIN BRIDGE FROM THE GRADE 294 ONE..-MODEL 1,3/4 PLATE.
IF THE SERIAL NUMBERS MATCH ON BOTH,TRAIN AND BARREL BRIDGE,IS IT POSSIBLE THAT THE VERY FIRST RUN OF THE YEAR 1906 WAS A MIXED RUN OF OPEN AND HUNTING MOVEMENTS?

ANDREA
April 22, 2009, 14:12
Ernie Loga
Andrea: Everything is possible. Every absolute has exceptions. So it could be possible that South Bend made a few 294's as open face watches but I rather doubt it.

I don't think the Ebay watch is a 295 with a 294 train bridge. The 295 has gold lettering and a slightly different damaskeening. It is not a 294 as the location of the ratchet wheels and main wheels are opposite to the 294 pictured in the SB Forum.

At this point I am not sure what the ebay watch was or is. It is a mystery. Maybe Frank or Lindell can shed some light on it.
April 22, 2009, 14:25
Ernie Loga
Here is a picture of a South Bend 294 from run 2:


April 22, 2009, 14:26
Ernie Loga
Here is a picture of a south Bend 295 from run 1:


May 06, 2009, 23:34
Ernie Loga
I think I have figured out the problem. When the research was done for the 294 and 295 there was an erro done and some of the numbers didn't get divided out right. I believe there was a misconception that grade runs started with XXX001 when in fact hey could have started in the middle range.

We found the same recording problem with grade 120 and 121.
May 07, 2009, 13:26
Jerry Freedman
Here is my 294. It is not marked!


May 07, 2009, 14:04
Lindell V. Riddle

Now, very carefully compare the two images above and you will see the train bridge cannot be interchanged between Hunter Case and Open Face South-Bend movements. Without question the watch this topic began with is an Open Face movement.

Two points to remember...

• The 294 represented the top grade of South-Bend First Model Hunter movements.

•• South-Bend routinely produced their movements in mixed runs as did most watch companies.

From those facts along with the evidence before us it then becomes clear there were lesser grades produced within the 294 run in question. And this also confirms something I have long held, there were far fewer of the Grade 294 produced than is commonly believed. For those reasons I would place 294 production at being 1,000 or less.

Lindell

Wink